Showing posts with label magic wand. Show all posts
Showing posts with label magic wand. Show all posts

Thursday, November 19, 2015

[AM_20151119] Anticipation and Bridging as Proof Tactics

Question

Introduction
     In a previous article, I have showed an “evil” tactic that can be used against “evil” questions.  Here is another “evil” trigonometric proof question.
     Many traditionalist school teachers insist on starting either from the LHS or the RHS, and working all the way to the other side.  Personally I do not mind any form of presentation as long as it is logical.  But not many students are able to do that.  People tend to fall into the trap of beginning a proof with the statement that they are supposed to prove in the first place.  This is called circular reasoning (or “begging the question” or petitio principii).  It is definitely a no-no.  So there is some advantage to sticking to the traditionalist mould.  The disadvantage is, of course, that it stifles creativity and this gives a misleading image of mathematics to the learner.

More “Evil” Tactics
     Now, if we do not want to “break the rules”, perhaps we can “bend the rules” a little.  On a piece of rough paper, or in your mind, secretly work from both sides and try to bridge them in the middle.  Let us compare
Think:  How are they similar?  How are they different?
As you can see, the LHS already has a preponderance of  cos 75°.  One of these  cos 75°  must somehow disappear.  The  RHS  has  4 sin 75°  which the LHS does not have.  So if we start from the LHS, we can use our magic wand [SV4] to create  4 sin 75°  out of thin air, remembering to divide by the same thing, so that the original value does not get changed.

Solution



Reflection
     Have you learned anything from this problem?  Let us review the heuristics used to help us solve this problem successfully.


H04. Look for pattern(s)
H05. Work backwards
H09. Restate the problem in another way
H10. Simplify the problem
H11. Solve part of the problem

Special Variants of Heuristics (Good for Trigonometric Proofs)
SV1   Work from both sides and try to bridge them in the middle [~ H04]
SV2   comparing (similarities/differences) what you have now with what you want [~ H05]
SV3   anticipate what will happen in the end and what you must do now [~ H05]
SV4   Magic Wand or create something out of nothing (无中生有) [~ H09]

Suitable Levels
* GCE ‘O’ Level Additional Mathematics
* IB SL & HL Mathematics (revision)
* other syllabuses that involve trigonometry

* just about anyone who is interested, really

Tuesday, November 17, 2015

[AM_20151117] An “Unorthodox” Technique for Trigonometric Proof

Question

Introduction
     When proving trigonometrical identities, one usually starts from the “more difficult” side and try to work towards the other side.  The above identity looks like a tough nut to crack.  Both sides look equally complicated.  Where do we even begin?
     Here is one way to “cheat”.  Starting from, say, the LHS, we multiply the RHS expression and also multiply by its reciprocal i.e. dividing by the same amount.  It is like using a magic wand to create something out of nothing (无中生有 in Chinese), but doing so does not change the value of the LHS expression.  Now we do not touch the part that is equal to the RHS (highlighted in yellow below), but we try to find a way to cancel away the other stuff, as shown here.

Solution

Remarks
     In the third step, I had replaced  cos2A  with  1 – sin2A  and  sin2B  with  1 – cos2B.  This leads to the required cancellation and we are left with the yellow patch, which was never touched since the first step and it is the RHS.  This completes the proof.
     Just as in martial arts where deadly opponents require deadly strokes to counter them, evil questions require “unorthodox” techniques.  Even though most people would not have thought of it, all the steps presented above are actually legitimate.  This is because at every step, the equality is preserved.  All the “=” are really equal, and it’s legit (either work hard or you might as well quit), although my “can’t touch this” tactic seems a bit clairvoyant.
. 
H04. Look for pattern(s)
H05. Work backwards
H08. Make suppositions
H09. Restate the problem in another way
H10. Simplify the problem
H11. Solve part of the problem
H13* Use Equation / write a Mathematical Sentence

Suitable Levels
* GCE ‘O’ Level Additional Mathematics
* other syllabuses that involve proof of trigonometric identities
* anyone who loves mathematical challenges